New trial date set for dentist accused of covering up murder

Busch Melissa 2 Crop Headshot

A dentist in Kentucky who is accused of helping his son cover up the 2023 murder of a 38-year-old woman will not have his day in court until the spring of 2026, according to multiple stories published on December 2.

Dr. Michael K. McKinney II.Dr. Michael K. McKinney II.Floyd County Smiles.

Dr. Michael K. McKinney II -- a dentist who was charged with eight counts of complicity to tampering with evidence in connection with the murder of Amber Spradlin -- his son Michael “M.K.” McKinney III, who is charged with murder, and Josh Mullins, who is accused of tampering with evidence, head to trial on May 11, 2026, according to the stories.

The trial was initially scheduled to begin in December 2025; however, it was delayed after the prosecution requested more time to finish DNA testing.

In July 2024, Michael "M.K." McKinney III was charged with murder and eight counts of complicity to tampering with evidence. McKinney II, along with Mullins, was arrested and accused with M.K. McKinney III of engaging in a "complicated scheme" to conceal the handle of the knife used to slay Spradlin, destroying M.K. McKinney III's clothing and cleaning up the woman's blood in the sink and laundry room of the dentist's house. Also, Mullins is charged with eight counts of complicity in tampering with evidence.

Additionally, the men allegedly destroyed a surveillance camera that would have captured the murder and the video recorder with footage from the surveillance cameras, as well as the hard drive of the only computer in the home that would have had information about the cameras.

On June 17, 2023, Spradlin finished her shift at a restaurant owned by the elder McKinney and then allegedly left with the dentist and another man and headed to an inn. Eventually, they arrived at the dentist's home. On June 18, 2023, 911 was called to the home, where authorities found that Spradlin had been stabbed 11 times in the head, neck, and throat.

In September 2024, the Kentucky Board of Dentistry lifted the temporary dental license suspension of the eldest McKinney. One month earlier, McKinney II was granted permission to help train another dentist to keep his practice, Floyd County Smiles, from going out of business, but he was prohibited from providing any dental care himself.

Page 1 of 89
Next Page